CaratHunter
Plans
Heart|Natural|GIA

2.51ct I VS1 Heart Natural Diamond

ID • I/VS1 • GIA 2

Certificate GIA 2

Diamond specifications and retailer prices

From $26,259 CAD
$18,798 USD
As of October 30, 2026
Save $5,410 CAD (17%) vs most expensive(unlock to see where)
3 retailers carry this diamond
Most expensive: $31,669 CAD at Blue Nile · As of October 31, 2026
View at Blue Nile

About this 2.51ct natural heart diamond

This 2.51ct natural heart sits in the two to three carat band, graded I colour (near-colourless) and VS1 clarity (very-slightly-included), with a top-tier cut grade stated by the retailer rather than the lab and certified by GIA. Listed at 3 retailers as of October 30, 2026, with prices from $26,259 to $31,669, a $5,410 spread on the same certified stone. Blue Nile lists it at $31,669. At this carat range, natural pricing varies dramatically across retailers, so the cross-retailer spread on this exact stone is your single best indicator of fair price.

The 4Cs

2.51
Carat
I
Color
VS1
Clarity
Ideal
Cut (retailer stated)

Specifications

Cut (retailer stated)Ideal
PolishExcellent
SymmetryExcellent
FluorescenceFaint
OriginNatural
Grading LabGIA
CertificateGIA 2
Dimensions8.61 × 9.48 × 5.40 mm
L/W Ratio1.10
Top View
8.61 mm9.48 mm2.51 ctI / VS1
OriginNatural
CutIdeal
PolishExcellent
SymmetryExcellent
FluorescenceFaint
CertificateGIA 2
Side View
Table 58.0%CrownGirdle: MED-THKPavilionCulet: NoneDepth 56.9%

Caratlytics Score

How it works →
A
Excellent
Excellent quality and great value
Unlock full score analysis
See the detailed 0 to 100 score with Quality, Value, Certification & Market breakdown

Price History

Last verified: Oct 30
Current: $31,669 CAD|Low: $25,987 CAD|High: $42,843 CAD|Avg: $31,960 CAD
Blue Nile
Retailer 2
Retailer 3
Retailer 4
Retailer 5
Retailer 6
September 23, 2026
Retailer 2$26,259 CAD
Retailer 6$28,012 CAD
Blue Nile$31,669 CAD
Retailer 4$32,763 CAD
Retailer 5$34,023 CAD
Retailer 3$42,843 CAD

3 data points across 6 retailers

3 retailers$26,259 CAD to $31,669 CAD

A
Cheapest Retailer
-
$26,259 CAD
$18,798 USD
A
Retailer 2
-
$28,012 CAD
$20,053 USD
View
Most Expensive
B+
Blue Nile
21828735 · Oct 31
$31,669 CAD
$22,671 USD
View
2 more retailers have this diamond
Prices start from $26,259 CADSave up to $5,410 CAD

Carat Hunter is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any retailer listed. Retailer information is from publicly available sources and may not be current. Verify details directly with the retailer before purchasing. Return terms as we hold them. Check the retailer's own returns page before you buy.

A
2.51ct Heart
$26,259 CAD