How to spot a fish-eye in a round diamond before you buy
A fish-eye is a ring of reflected girdle that shows just inside the edge of the table when you look at a round diamond face up. GIA's research links it to a pavilion cut too shallow, with a large table and a low crown adding to it, and says a diamond should not display one. In this model, a round with a 37 degree pavilion angle and 56.4% total depth shows the ring, and the same round at 40.8 degrees and 61.9% does not.
Written by Carat Hunter, an independent diamond price comparison site that does not sell diamonds. Last checked against its sources on .
What does a good round look like?
Turn it. The pattern is even from the table out to the edge, with no pale ring. This round has a pavilion angle of 40.8 degrees.
Drag to turnThis model's figures
- Pavilion angle40.8°Good: No ring in this model
- Crown angle34.5°
- Table56%
- Depth61.9%
- Girdlemedium
- Culetpointed
Good and Watch mark whether a figure is inside or outside a range GIA or IGI publishes; where no range applies, the note describes the model only.
A fish-eye and a good round, side by side
One round of about 1 ct, modelled twice. Only the pavilion angle changes.
Drag to turn
Drag to turnWhat differs, in these models
Good: no ring
- Pavilion angle40.8°Good: No ring in this model
- Depth61.9%
Poor: fish-eye
- Pavilion angle37.0°Watch: A low pavilion angle makes a fish-eye more likely
- Depth56.4%
Good and Watch mark whether a figure is inside or outside a range GIA or IGI publishes; where no range applies, the note describes the model only.
Drag either stone; both turn together.
Modelled illustrations from one stone's measurements, not listings.
What causes a fish-eye?
In a round with a shallow pavilion you see the reflection of the girdle in the table, as a ring just inside the edge. GIA's research names a pavilion that is too shallow as a cause, and its 2004 cut study describes a fish-eye produced by a large table with a shallow crown. This model shows the ring at the shallower angle and not at the deeper one; in real stones the table size and crown height matter too, so there is no single angle where it starts.
Will my report say fish-eye?
No. A grading report has no line for a fish-eye. For a standard round brilliant, GIA gives a cut grade, and GIA's booklet on estimating that grade says the pattern it weighs includes the point of tilt at which a fish-eye appears. The report gives the grade without the reasons for it, so look for the ring yourself.
Fish-eye, dark centre or window?
All three make the middle of a diamond look wrong, and you tell them apart by what you see. GIA's research links a fish-eye to a pavilion cut too shallow and a dark centre to one cut too deep, and a window also comes from a shallow pavilion. The figures below are this site's models, not limits for real stones.
- Fish-eye
- A pale or grey ring just inside the edge of the table: the girdle, reflected. In this model it shows in a round with a 37 degree pavilion angle, 56.4% deep.
- Dark centre
- A dull patch in the middle of the table that stays dark when the stone is tilted. In this model it shows in a round with a 45 degree pavilion angle, 68.7% deep.
- Window
- A see-through middle that takes on the look of whatever is behind the stone. In this model it shows in an oval with a 36% pavilion depth, 53.6% deep.
In these models, the round with a 40.8 degree pavilion angle, 61.9% deep, shows neither a ring nor a dark centre, and the oval with a 44% pavilion depth, 61.6% deep, shows no window.
What to check on a listing
- Look at the face-up photo or video for a ring inside the table. It sits just inside the edge of the table, and tilting the stone can make it stronger.
- Depth. A round that is shallow for its width may have a shallow pavilion, or a low crown. A low depth is a reason to look closer, but on its own it does not tell you which.
- Pavilion angle, when the report gives it. A low angle makes the ring more likely, together with a large table and a low crown.
On Carat Hunter
A round's page shows its table and depth as the report gives them, and its crown and pavilion angles when we have them. Lucy's take on a round can say when its depth is shallower than most rounds we track, or its table larger than most. No figure on the page shows the ring itself, so treat those as reasons to watch the video closely.
Sources
- GIA 4Cs: Diamond Cut
- GIA 4Cs: GIA Diamond Cut Grade, 6 Things to Know
- GIA: GIA Researchers Evaluate ‘Light Performance’ and Diamond Cut
- GIA, Gems & Gemology, Fall 2004: A Foundation for Grading the Overall Cut Quality of Round Brilliant Cut Diamonds (Moses et al.)
- GIA: Estimating a Cut Grade Using the GIA Diamond Cut Grading System
- GIA: How to Read a GIA Diamond Grading Report (2026)