Skip to main content
Oval, Natural, GIA

4.58ct J I2 Oval Natural Diamond

CertificateGIA 6545765605

Diamond specifications and retailer prices

Price

From$21,555USDAs of November 18, 2026Fresh
Retailers
8 retailers
Caratlytics grade
A
Excellent
Every price for this diamond
Save $12,028 USD (36%) vs most expensive
Ask Lucy

2 free unlocks for registered users

View at Carat EU

Every listing for this diamond

Cheapest first
1Nov 18, 2026, FreshA$21,555
2Nov 18, 2026, FreshB+$23,816
3Nov 18, 2026, Fresh$24,111
4Nov 17, 2026, FreshB+$24,732
5Nov 18, 2026, FreshB+$27,406
6Nov 17, 2026, FreshB+$27,846
7Nov 18, 2026, FreshB+$31,949
8SKU 58a4c619-9642-40de-9ae7-78a7e5e7ffd0Nov 17, 2026, FreshB+$33,583
In the free view retailers are unnamed, except the most expensive. Unlock the diamond to see who sells at each price.
Carat Hunter is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any retailer listed. Retailer information is from publicly available sources and may not be current. Verify details directly with the retailer before purchasing. Return terms as we hold them. Check the retailer's own returns page before you buy.

Caratlytics Score

How it works
A
ExcellentExcellent quality and great value

The exact score and its four parts open with an unlock or the Pass.

From the GIA report

GIA 6545765605
Table57.0%Measurements13.63 × 9.16 × 5.78 mm
Proportions
Carat
4.58
13.63 × 9.16 × 5.78 mm
Color
J
Near Colorless, Slightly tinted white
Clarity
I2
Included
Cut (retailer stated)
Ideal
Cut (retailer stated)
Ideal
Polish
Excellent
Symmetry
Excellent
Fluorescence
Strong
Table
57.0%
Depth
63.1%
Measurements
13.63 × 9.16 × 5.78 mm
L/W Ratio
1.49
Girdle
Slightly Thick to Thick
Culet
None
Girdle condition
Faceted
Key to symbols
Crystal, Feather, Needle, Indented Natural, Natural

Proportion CheckCheck this one

Price History

Lowest
$21,555
Highest
$33,583
Average
$26,330

Select a retailer to show or hide its line, up to 5 at once.

About this 4.58ct natural oval diamond

This 4.58ct natural oval sits in the three to five carat band, graded J colour (near-colourless) and I2 clarity (included), with a top-tier cut grade stated by the retailer rather than the lab and certified by GIA 6545765605. Listed at 8 retailers as of November 17, 2026, with prices from $21,555 to $33,583, a $12,028 spread on the same certified stone. Carat EU lists it at $33,583. At this carat range, natural pricing varies dramatically across retailers, so the cross-retailer spread on this exact stone is your single best indicator of fair price.