メインコンテンツへ移動
Carat Hunter Research

The same diamond, very different prices

The identical certified diamond, same lab, same report number, same physical stone, often sells for 30% to 80% more at one retailer than another. This is what that spread looks like across the market.

Average left on the table on a 1-carat identical certified stone
$1,737
How much more the same stone can cost at one retailer versus another
30% to 80%
Total active price spread across all cross-retailer matched stones
$7.49B
Retailers tracked, across 19 countries
105+

What is diamond price dispersion?

It is the gap in price for the identical product across different sellers. For diamonds it is unusually large: the same certified stone, with the same grading report, commonly costs 30% to 80% more at one retailer than another.

How much do diamond prices vary between retailers?

For the same physical certified stone, Carat Hunter typically sees a 30% to 80% gap between the cheapest and dearest listing, averaging about $1,737 on a one carat. Lab-grown stones disperse more widely than natural.

Why does the same diamond cost different amounts at different shops?

Many retailers source from the same wholesale platforms, then price the same stone differently. Because it is hard for buyers to compare the exact stone across stores, those price differences persist rather than being competed away.

What we found

Many online retailers draw from the same wholesale supply, so the same physical diamond, identified by its grading report number, turns up at five, ten, sometimes twenty different stores. The grading is identical. The price is not.

The cheapest retailer for a given stone is not fixed. It moves over time, so no single store is always cheapest. For a buyer, that means the only reliable way to find the best price is to compare the exact stone across retailers at the moment of purchase.

How we measured it

Carat Hunter matches the same physical diamond across retailers using the grading report number and a physical fingerprint built from the stone's measurements and grades. When the same stone appears at more than one retailer, the listings are grouped and the prices compared directly.

These are active listing prices, not recorded sale prices, so the spread describes what is on offer rather than what every buyer ends up paying. Sample depth varies by specification.

What it means if you are buying

If you are shopping for a certified diamond, do not assume one retailer's price is the market price. Find the report number and check who else is selling that exact stone. The difference is often four figures for no difference in the diamond.

Carat Hunter is an independent diamond price-comparison platform. We take no affiliate or retailer commissions, so the data has no commercial axe to grind. Journalists and researchers are welcome to use these findings with attribution to Carat Hunter.

Carat Hunter is operated by Digital Adventures Pty Ltd. Independent, with no affiliate or retailer commissions. The figures on this page are based on Carat Hunter's cross-retailer index as of the stated date.