Skip to main content

How to spot a dark center in a round diamond before you buy

A dark center, which the trade also calls a nailhead, is a dull patch in the middle of the table that stays dark when the stone is tilted. GIA's research links it to a pavilion cut too deep, or to a crown and pavilion that do not match. In this model, a round with a 45 degree pavilion angle and 68.7% total depth has a dark, spoked center, and the same round at 40.8 degrees and 61.9% stays bright.

Written by Carat Hunter, an independent diamond price comparison site that does not sell diamonds. Last checked against its sources on .

What does a good round look like?

Turn it. The center is bright, and the small dark areas around it move as the stone moves. This round has a pavilion angle of 40.8 degrees.

A modeled round diamond seen face up: in this model an even pattern of dark arrows around a bright center.Drag to turn

This model's figures

  • Pavilion angle40.8°Good: A bright center in this model
  • Crown angle34.5°
  • Table56%
  • Depth61.9%
  • Girdlemedium
  • Culetpointed

Good and Watch mark whether a figure is inside or outside a range GIA or IGI publishes; where no range applies, the note describes the model only.

What does a good round look like?Modeled illustration, not a listing.
Arrow keys turn and tilt the stone; Home puts it back face up.

A dark center and a bright round, side by side

One round of about 1 ct, modeled twice. Only the pavilion angle changes.

A modeled round diamond seen face up: in this model an even pattern of dark arrows around a bright center.Drag to turn
Good: bright center.Pavilion angle 40.8 degrees, total depth 61.9%.
A modeled round diamond with a deep pavilion, seen face up: in this model its center looks dark.Drag to turn
Poor: dark center.Pavilion angle 45 degrees, total depth 68.7%. The center is dark and spoked.
Arrow keys turn and tilt the stone; Home puts it back face up.

What differs, in these models

Good: bright center

  • Pavilion angle40.8°Good: A bright center in this model
  • Depth61.9%

Poor: dark center

  • Pavilion angle45.0°Watch: A steep pavilion angle makes a dark center more likely
  • Depth68.7%

Good and Watch mark whether a figure is inside or outside a range GIA or IGI publishes; where no range applies, the note describes the model only.

Drag either stone; both turn together.

Modeled illustrations from one stone's measurements, not listings.

Why does a deep pavilion darken the center?

GIA's research names a pavilion that is too deep as a cause of a dark center. In real stones such a pavilion lets light escape instead of returning to the viewer, and the viewer's own reflection darkens the table too. In this model the deep pavilion sends the light that enters the center of the table back toward the viewer, so the center takes on the dark of the viewer's reflection.

Is a dark center the same as a nailhead?

Often, yes. A GIA Lab Note calls nailhead 'a term often applied to a poorly cut stone that is dark on the table.' A report will not use the word, but for a standard round GIA's cut grade takes in the stone's pattern of bright and dark areas. Read the grade and watch the video together.

Fish-eye, dark center or window?

All three make the middle of a diamond look wrong, and you tell them apart by what you see. GIA's research links a fish-eye to a pavilion cut too shallow and a dark center to one cut too deep, and a window also comes from a shallow pavilion. The figures below are this site's models, not limits for real stones.

Fish-eye
A pale or gray ring just inside the edge of the table: the girdle, reflected. In this model it shows in a round with a 37 degree pavilion angle, 56.4% deep.
Dark center
A dull patch in the middle of the table that stays dark when the stone is tilted. In this model it shows in a round with a 45 degree pavilion angle, 68.7% deep.
Window
A see-through middle that takes on the look of whatever is behind the stone. In this model it shows in an oval with a 36% pavilion depth, 53.6% deep.

In these models, the round with a 40.8 degree pavilion angle, 61.9% deep, shows neither a ring nor a dark center, and the oval with a 44% pavilion depth, 61.6% deep, shows no window.

What to check on a listing

  1. Watch the video face up and rocking. A center that stays dark at every angle is the one to walk away from.
  2. Depth. A round that is deep for its width may have a deep pavilion, or a thick girdle. The real point where a center goes dark depends on the other angles too.
  3. Pavilion angle, when the report gives it. A steep angle makes a dark center more likely.

On Carat Hunter

A round's page shows its depth and girdle as the report gives them, and its crown and pavilion angles when we have them. Lucy's take on a round can say when its depth is deeper than most rounds we track, which puts more of its weight below the girdle, and when its girdle runs very thick. The page cannot show the dark itself, so watch the video for a center that stays dark.

Sources