Skip to main content

How to read a diamond grading report, line by line

A diamond grading report records what a lab found when it examined a stone: its shape, measurements and carat weight, its color and clarity grades, a cut grade (which GIA gives only to standard round brilliants), its polish, symmetry and proportions and, on a full GIA report, a plot of its clarity characteristics. This guide goes through a typical GIA Diamond Grading Report line by line, then an IGI report, and points each line to the guide that says what to watch for.

Written by Carat Hunter, an independent diamond price comparison site that does not sell diamonds. Last checked against its sources on .

What is on a diamond grading report?

GIA describes its Diamond Grading Report as an assessment of the 4Cs (color, clarity, cut and carat weight), along with a plotted diagram of the clarity characteristics and a drawing of the proportions. GIA issues it for loose natural diamonds only; lab-grown diamonds get a GIA report of their own.

The sketch below shows the parts in one place. Select a part to read about it.

A simplified sketch drawn for this guide, not a copy of any lab's report.

Shape, measurements and carat weight

The shape is the diamond's outline, and the cutting style is the pattern its facets are arranged in, as in Round Brilliant.

The measurements are in millimeters. For a round, GIA gives the smallest and the largest diameter, then the depth; for other shapes, the length, width and depth. Length and width tell you how large a stone faces up.

The carat weight is given to two decimal places, such as 1.01 carats, and one carat is a fifth of a gram. A carat is a weight, not a size, so two stones of the same weight can face up at different sizes.

Why, and how to spot it:

Color grade

GIA grades color on a scale from D to Z by comparing the diamond with GIA's master comparison diamonds, from colorless at D to light yellow or brown at Z. An asterisk (*) next to the grade means GIA detected a color treatment.

A lab judges color face down, so the grade tells you how much color the stone has, not exactly how it looks face up or in a setting.

Tints, and how they show:

Clarity grade

GIA grades clarity from Flawless to Included, by the size, nature, number, position and relief of the characteristics visible at 10x magnification. The grade alone does not tell you what the inclusions are or where they sit; the plot and the key to symbols do.

What a grade means, and the inclusions you will meet most often:

Cut grade

GIA gives a cut grade, from Excellent to Poor, only for standard round brilliants in the D to Z color range. GIA says the grade takes in the diamond's face-up appearance, design and craftsmanship.

An oval, pear or other fancy shape has no GIA cut grade, so a cut grade shown next to a GIA oval is not GIA's. IGI grades cut on fancy shapes too, and publishes the proportion ranges it uses for an Excellent grade.

For eligible diamonds, GIA offers the AGS Ideal Report as a digital addition to its own report, and it can include an ASET Map, a color picture of where the stone's light comes from; our guide to reading an ASET image explains the colors.

What to look for in an oval, with or without a cut grade:

Polish, symmetry and fluorescence

Polish is the smoothness of the diamond's surface. Symmetry is the exactness of its outline and of the shape, placement and alignment of its facets. GIA grades both from Excellent to Poor.

Fluorescence describes the strength and color of the diamond under long-wave ultraviolet light; GIA reports it for identification, and None covers a range from indiscernible to very faint.

The proportions diagram

GIA calls this a profile of the diamond drawn to its actual proportions. On a round it gives the table, total depth, crown height and pavilion depth as percentages of the average girdle diameter, and the crown and pavilion angles in degrees. Here is what each figure measures, with the guide that covers it where there is one.

Table
The table facet on top, usually the largest facet. A large table with a low crown can add to a fish-eye. Read more: Fish-eye
Total depth
The height from the table to the culet. A round that is deep for its width can carry weight that does not show face up, and one that is shallow for its width may have a shallow pavilion. Read more: Hidden weight and spread
Crown angle and crown height
The angle between the bezel facets and the table, and the height of the crown from the table down to the girdle. A crown and pavilion that do not match can darken the table. Read more: A dark center, Extinction and contrast
Pavilion angle and pavilion depth
The angle between the pavilion main facets and the table, and the depth from the girdle down to the culet. A pavilion cut too shallow can leave a fish-eye in a round, or a window; one cut too deep can leave a dark center. Read more: Fish-eye, Windowing, A dark center
Girdle
The band around the edge. The report gives its thickness as one word or a range, such as Medium to Slightly Thick, and can say whether it is bruted, polished or faceted. Read more: Thin and thick girdles
Culet
The small facet at the bottom, when there is one; None means there is no culet facet. A large culet can show face up as a small circle in the center. Read more: A large culet
Star length and lower half length
On a round, the lengths of the star facets and of the lower half facets, as percentages. No guide here covers them yet.

The plot and key to symbols

A full GIA report includes a plotted diagram: an outline of the diamond's shape and cutting style, seen from the crown and from the pavilion, with symbols that show the type, position and approximate size of its clarity characteristics. Red symbols mark inclusions, and green or black symbols mark blemishes. The key to symbols lists the characteristics shown on the plot, such as a crystal, a cloud or a feather.

The report notes that the diagram is approximate, that not every clarity characteristic may be shown, and that details of finish are not shown. The plot is drawn flat, so a mark in the middle of the crown view may sit under the table, in the crown or deeper in the pavilion.

If a report has no plot, its clarity grade and comments are all it tells you about the inclusions, so the video matters more.

Comments

GIA uses the comments for identifying characteristics or features that are not otherwise shown on the report. If GIA detects a treatment, such as laser drilling, it is described here.

Read a comment for what its words say and no more. "Additional clouds are not shown" says that the plot leaves some clouds out. "Clarity grade is based on clouds that are not shown" says that clouds count in the grade but are not on the plot. Either way the plot tells you less about the clouds, so the video matters more.

More on clouds:

The report number, and checking it with the lab

Each GIA report carries a unique report number, registered in GIA's database, and the date GIA examined the diamond. The inscription line lists any text, symbols, logos or report number inscribed on the girdle. The report also states that it is not a guarantee or valuation.

GIA's Report Check, on its website, finds a report by its number. The QR code on a report checks its data against GIA's database when scanned. GIA's reports for lab-grown diamonds are digital only, and GIA says that if such a report can be found on Report Check, it is authentic.

IGI says each of its reports can be traced through a unique report number and, often, a QR code, and that reports can be verified through the IGI website.

A report number alone does not show that the stone in front of you is the one the report describes. GIA has found lab-grown diamonds cut to nearly match GIA-graded natural diamonds and inscribed with those natural stones' report numbers, and it offers its clients a service that confirms a diamond's inscription matches its report number.

If a listing hides the report number, Carat Hunter's free Certificate Decoder can help you find it.

How is an IGI report different from a GIA report?

IGI's own guide to reading its reports says each report has a unique report number, often with a QR code, and that a laser inscription on the stone is optional.

IGI grades cut on fancy shapes as well as rounds, which GIA does not. For ovals, its published guidelines for an Excellent cut grade set proportion ranges, require that the bow-tie is not significant, and make the final grade subject to visual confirmation.

What to check on a listing

  1. Check the report number with the lab. Use GIA's Report Check or IGI's Verify Your Report, and compare what the lab shows with the listing's grades and measurements.
  2. Read past the four grades. The proportions diagram, the plot, the key to symbols and the comments say things the grades do not. Note which characteristics the key lists and where the plot puts them.
  3. Note which grades the lab gave. A GIA report gives no cut grade for a fancy shape, so a cut grade on such a listing is not GIA's.

On Carat Hunter

A stone's page shows the lab and report number and, for a GIA or IGI report, a link to the lab's own page for that report. It shows the four Cs and, where they are known, the report's other lines: polish, symmetry, fluorescence, table, depth, measurements, crown and pavilion angles, girdle, culet, comments and the key to symbols, many with a short note, along with a drawing of the stone from the report's figures. Where the lab does not grade cut on a stone's shape, any cut grade on the page is marked as stated by the retailer.

Sources