Diamond flaws to avoid, and how to spot them before you buy
Some faults that make a diamond look worse never appear on its grading report, or show only as a word or a number. GIA reports have no line for windows, and GIA does not grade cut on ovals; IGI's Excellent grade for an oval requires that the bow-tie is not significant. So a window, or a bow-tie that is faint or strong, is left for you to judge. Each guide here shows one problem on a modeled stone next to a good one, and lists what to check before you buy.
Written by Carat Hunter, an independent diamond price comparison site that does not sell diamonds. Last checked against its sources on .
Is it cut well?
GIA gives a cut grade only to standard round brilliants, so on an oval or another fancy shape these are faults you judge from the stone and its video.
A bow-tie in an oval
Almost every oval shows a darker band across its middle. How to tell a faint bow-tie from a strong one before you buy.
Windowing
A see-through patch where light leaks out of a stone that is cut too shallow.
Fish-eye
A ring of reflected girdle inside the edge of the table, in a round with a shallow pavilion.
A dark center
A dark middle in a round whose pavilion is cut too deep.
Extinction and contrast
Every diamond has dark areas and needs some for contrast. When there is too much, and how your own reflection adds to it.
How to read an ASET image
What the red, green and blue of an ASET image mean, shown on modeled stones, with the Ideal Scope for comparison.
Is it the size its weight says?
A carat is a weight, not a size, so two stones of the same weight can face up at different sizes.
Hidden weight and spread
Two stones of the same carat weight, one that faces up smaller.
Thin and thick girdles
The band around a diamond's edge: what the report's words mean, why a very thin girdle can chip, and why a very thick one adds weight without size.
A large culet
The small facet at the bottom of the stone: the report's scale from None to Extremely Large, and when a large one shows face up.
Oval shoulders, flat or bulging
Flat and bulging shoulders at the same length and width, in GIA's words, and how the weight can differ.
Diamond size on your hand
A diamond in one of nine common shapes, from 0.5 to 5 carats, on your ring finger at true size, with your phone's camera.
Is it clean?
A clarity grade weighs the size, number, position, kind and relief of the inclusions together, so it does not say what an inclusion is, where it sits or whether you will see it.
Clarity grades, and what they miss
GIA's 11 clarity grades in GIA's words, the five things a grade weighs, why a grade is not a size or a map, and whether eye-clean is a grade.
Crystals and where they sit
A mineral trapped inside the stone: why one under the table shows more than one near the girdle, and a dark one more than a white one.
Feathers
A break inside the stone that can flash white at one angle and nearly vanish at the next, and when one near the girdle or at the surface matters.
Clouds and pinpoints
Many pinpoints close together: when a cloud stays out of sight face up, when it makes a stone look hazy, and what a report comment about clouds not shown means.
Is it white?
GIA grades color face down, so the grade tells you how much color a stone has, not exactly how it looks face up or in a setting.
Body color
A diamond's own faint tint: why a lab grades it face down, and why an oval can show it at the tips.
Is the report right?
A grading report records what the lab found when it examined the stone. Read it past the four grades, and check the report number with the lab.
How to read a diamond report
A GIA and an IGI report, line by line: what each line and drawing records, which guide covers it, and how to check a report with the lab.
Off-center culet and table
What a symmetry grade covers, shown with a round whose culet or table sits off the middle.
How these guides are made
The stones are 3D models built from measurements: table, depth, crown and pavilion angles, girdle and culet. Your browser draws each one by tracing light through its facets. A comparison usually changes one thing and keeps the rest the same; when it changes more, the page says which. Automated tests check that the main comparison on most pages shows what its caption says. Figures marked "in this model" describe the model only: they are not limits for real diamonds, and the models have no grades.
Every statement about real diamonds is checked against the sources listed at the end of its page: GIA and IGI publications and peer-reviewed research. If none of them backs a statement, we change it or take it out. Any range given for real stones is one GIA or IGI publishes.